Guns and paranoid citizens.

106 replies jump to bottom
trypdwyre
Joined: 01/29/2003
User offline. Last seen 5 years 2 weeks ago.

[QUOTE=gobo_fraggle_uk]if you'd read my posts (above), you'd know that I didn't argue for the removal of guns from US society, and I also pointed out that guns are allowed in other countries for hunting etc. but are more strictly controlled... what you're doing is called a 'straw man' argument - fighting a false opponent...
so: good for you too, but this is not related to anything i said.
and you think that just because i quote you i am only talking to you? did i say you were for removal of guns? no, you seem to be fighting an argument for something you don't believe in, with statistics of merely 2 countries.

gobo_fraggle_uk wrote:
In logic, If A then B, A, therefore B, is a valid argument. i.e. If there are no guns then the homicide rate is lower, there are no guns, therefore the homicide rate is lower - this is a valid argument. But you're saying If A then B, B, therefore A, is invalid - that having a low homicide rate does not require no guns (e.g. Switzerland) - and you're right. But you're necessarily right, in a mundane and logically obvious sense - and this in no way refutes the claim that 'if there are no guns then the homicide rate is lower'... because the term used was 'if' and not 'if and only if'. All you did was point out that a logically invalid form of argument (which you came up with) doesn't work - which is true by definition.

and let me ask you, do you think it's even possible to remove all guns from a society? why argue an ideal which will most certainly NOT happen? there is no possible or conceivable way to remove all guns, even from just one nations...
gobo_fraggle_uk wrote:
i had responded to trypdwyre saying that 'humanity' has a need for death by pointing out that other countries have lower murder rates and that it isn't a 'humanity' issue - you responded by falsely claiming that the US rate is not higher than those of other countries.
Your NZ example (if correct) reinforces my point, re. homicide rates in US (that they are atypically high).

did i say your rate was higher? no, i believe i said that we have well over 4 times the number of people you do. if you want to infer from that, maybe infer something along the lines of group mentalities. since america has more populace, it's conceiveable that ther reason our rates are higher is due to "mob mentality". rates in the us are high, but that still has no correlation to how gun control, or lack of, affects gun related homicides.
gobo_fraggle_uk wrote:
On this we can agree. Let's enjoy a cocktail and contemplate the sunrise.[/QUOTE]
indeed. cheers mate.
DillingerEscape
DillingerEscape's picture
From: Bardo
Joined: 01/06/2003
User offline. Last seen 7 years 15 weeks ago.

[QUOTE=trypdwyre]
did i say your rate was higher? no, i believe i said that we have well over 4 times the number of people you do. if you want to infer from that, maybe infer something along the lines of group mentalities. since america has more populace, it's conceiveable that ther reason our rates are higher is due to "mob mentality". rates in the us are high, but that still has no correlation to how gun control, or lack of, affects gun related homicides.
[/QUOTE]

Learned a good bit about that pysch classes. The attitudes of higher populations. Can't remember the 'term' for it the class was about 2 years ago. It's like the mob mentality but on a larger but more 'subtle' scale. As strange as that may sound.

So it's usually easier to ask for someone to explain what they mean with a stat or quote they may have on these boards rather than jump in someone's shit and try to talk down to them. Sometimes I may just say some shit not thinking you will all need it broken down for you. If I say some shit that may seem off the wall or a little out of play, just let me know, I'll break it down for you kindergarten style. But anyway...... carry on.

__________________________

Your eyes are yours to close.
Never let go, Sleep is wrong.
When I grow up I'm never gonna sleep.
When I grow up I'm never gonna cry.
When I go out I'm never coming home.
When I grow up I'm never gonna die.
~SGM

joeyjojojrshabadoo
From: 19 A Fucking Way
Joined: 11/10/2004
User offline. Last seen 8 years 24 weeks ago.

If it's about mob mentality, then a better solution would be Fear Control, instead of gun control. If live in a major North American city where loads of people don't even lock their doors. I don't lock my door, I never have. Might get robbed one day, might not. I'm not scared of being robbed so I don't own a weapon. I wouldn't buy a gun if there was gun control or not. I think guns should be a personal decision, but it just seems odd giving people easy access to weapons. A nine millimetre hand gun is not for hunting wabbits, it's for putting big holes in human beings.

__________________________

You gotta get behind the mule in the morning and plow.

DillingerEscape
DillingerEscape's picture
From: Bardo
Joined: 01/06/2003
User offline. Last seen 7 years 15 weeks ago.

[QUOTE=joeyjojojrshabadoo]If it's about mob mentality, then a better solution would be Fear Control, instead of gun control. If live in a major North American city where loads of people don't even lock their doors. I don't lock my door, I never have. Might get robbed one day, might not. I'm not scared of being robbed so I don't own a weapon. I wouldn't buy a gun if there was gun control or not. I think guns should be a personal decision, but it just seems odd giving people easy access to weapons. A nine millimetre hand gun is not for hunting wabbits, it's for putting big holes in human beings.[/QUOTE]

I agree, I don't own a gun, have no need for a gun. I wouldn't mind there being a ban on certain types of weapons, but not all weapons. But I do lock my doors.

__________________________

Your eyes are yours to close.
Never let go, Sleep is wrong.
When I grow up I'm never gonna sleep.
When I grow up I'm never gonna cry.
When I go out I'm never coming home.
When I grow up I'm never gonna die.
~SGM

joeyjojojrshabadoo
From: 19 A Fucking Way
Joined: 11/10/2004
User offline. Last seen 8 years 24 weeks ago.

Part of me says ban em all. Part of me is ignorant and intolerant of other people's needs. Part of me says that if someone buys a gun for protection then they got it with the idea of shooting another person with it. Part of me says I don't what is best for everyone.

__________________________

You gotta get behind the mule in the morning and plow.

DillingerEscape
DillingerEscape's picture
From: Bardo
Joined: 01/06/2003
User offline. Last seen 7 years 15 weeks ago.

[QUOTE=joeyjojojrshabadoo]Part of me says ban em all. Part of me is ignorant and intolerant of other people's needs. Part of me says that if someone buys a gun for protection then they got it with the idea of shooting another person with it. Part of me says I don't what is best for everyone.[/QUOTE]

You've got alot of parts.

__________________________

Your eyes are yours to close.
Never let go, Sleep is wrong.
When I grow up I'm never gonna sleep.
When I grow up I'm never gonna cry.
When I go out I'm never coming home.
When I grow up I'm never gonna die.
~SGM