My first post....and already I need advice...

1 reply jump to bottom
mrsi24
mrsi24's picture
From: NH
Joined: 12/12/2007
User offline. Last seen 5 years 12 weeks ago.

Hello all,

I am new to the site, but not new to Chuck's books.  I have been a fan for a few years and have read them all (I think) anyway, I love the site and have spent some time skimming through the contents and forum posts.  However I wonder if the more experienced members can offer me some advice.  I recently joined a book club with some women who are mostly friends of a friend.  The first book we were "forced" to read was a depressing chick lit novel, I'll be kind enough not to name.  Well I read the book, went to the meeting and was the only one there who found said book to be, well, lame.  Low and behold, as per the rules of the club, my name was drawn out of a hat and I was allowed to choose the next book.  I originally planned on something by John Irving, but was met with disgruntled groans of disaproval...I decided these ladies needed something completely original, thus I chose "Invisible Monsters" (a favorite of mine) Not one woman recognized the title or author, and I was feeling mischevious and promised them a great read.  I really wanted to take them out of their comfort zones, and honestly thought even if they didn't approve of the subject matter they could at least appreciate Chucks talent as a writer.  The problem I have is this, the meeting is this weekend, and the early book club rumors are not pretty.  No one it seems, enjoyed the book.  The general consensus is that there was no meaning behind the story!  Now I feel like I have to defend my choice (which technically I do not, because that's part club, to experience new writers) but these ladies are vultures, and I know I'll be cornered (which is why book clubs are fun) But how do I possibly respond to the opinion that the book lacks plot and substance?  How would you guys as fans?  Thanks guys, I appreciate any advice!

nathaniel parker
Sprung
nathaniel parker's picture
From: Outer spiral arm of Milky Way
Joined: 06/24/2005
User offline. Last seen 14 weeks 4 days ago.

It's been a while since I read it but I always took from it being about reinventing yourself. Completely stripping away all the things that other people place on your identity and rebuilding yourself into who you want to be.

 

You should go through the IM forum on here and i'm sure you'll find all sorts of ideas and arguements to present to the old biddies.

 

good luck and let us know how it turns out.