Evanescence covers 'Heart Shaped Box'

i thought she fell off a building and died.

Who's 'she'?

the chick from evanescence.
she fell off that building cause the dude lost hold of her hand, and she was falling and still singing..... i figured she died.
maybe it was one of them, whatcha call it, "special effects"?

THEY'RE COVERING NIRVANA. DO NOT DISTRACT FROM THE ORIGINAL POINT. Dear God.

[QUOTE][i]Originally posted by jane s. [/i]
[B]Who's 'she'? [/B][/QUOTE]
[IMG]http://www.evanescence.com/images/transparent_photo468x380.gif[/IMG]

where did you here about the cover, or have you guys heard it already, sorry i;min Oklahoma, we get music about a yaer after the fact here

fucking mainstream bubblegum biatch

Disguised christian rock

this is fucking awful, its like when Adema covered Alice in CHains's "nutshell"

I havent heard it.
Nirvana's overrated though.
So Evanscence, so it works.

oh no youre reputation of being a music conessiour is sullied. this is an outrage.

i wanna see one of these bands cover the melvins or something good.

Who's rep? Mine?

nono
jane s
other whiners

kl0pper, were you born with this sense of superiority or did you gain it through some kind of miserable upbringing? I liked you better when you made zero sense and everyone thought you were lame/funny.

I still think kl0ppers funny.
I still think you're not funny.
(By-the-by, can you remember before Kurt was wormfood? What were you? 5?)

I also find you not funny. I'm glad we feel mutually on this topic.

Does it matter how old I was when Kurt Cobain died? No. A) He is not Nirvana, he was simply a part of it, and Why should that matter? Does me liking them after the demise of the band automatically make me a poser? Didn't this get discussed to fucking death in the Kurt Cobain thread?

I just don't like kl0pper and his ultimate sense of "I'm right and you're wrong, you twat," and the fact that he can bitch about everything under the sun, but dear God, no one else can!

Who is Nirvana? Kurt, Dave Grohl, and ummmmm....?

[QUOTE][i]Originally posted by jane s. [/i]
[B]kl0pper, were you born with this sense of superiority or did you gain it through some kind of miserable upbringing? I liked you better when you made zero sense and everyone thought you were lame/funny. [/B][/QUOTE]
I liked you before you became pretentious on the forums and you were nicer to talk to.

[QUOTE][i]Originally posted by jane s.[/i]
[B]I just don't like kl0pper and his ultimate sense of "I'm right and you're wrong, you twat,"[/B][/QUOTE]
I also dislike this... It's like his opinion is the only one that matters. Where's WillTupper when you need him? :confused:

Good comeback. You've completely changed my mind.

[QUOTE][i]Originally posted by Diabetic [/i]
[B]I liked you before you became pretentious on the forums and you were nicer to talk to.

[/B][/QUOTE]

Okay, you. You fucker. I've said this before a couple of times, and I've never gotten a response: who the hell are you? Do you know me? Do you know anything about me apart from what I post here, or what other people's opinions of me are? No. You don't. I can change any damn way I want to, have any opinion I want to, and you can do fuck all about it. Okay?

No one's sayin you can't. He's just sayin' you're a bitch. And I agree, because I want to.

Yeah, but where does he get this information from? That's all I want to know. I don't care whether he thinks I'm a bitch now or not; that's not the issue. My issue is how the fuck he thinks he's able to make an accurate comparison.

I get my information from these forums, the only way I know how. I have been visiting this place since June, and you were nice then. You always agreed with people and stuff. But since August or so, you've been irritable. The only reason I call you these things is because you called yourself a bitch, so I [i]thought[/i] you had a sense of humor.

I am by no means attacking you, so calm down. Just because you are a bitch doesn't mean you can't also be cool.

i dont care what persona you liked better
ive always hated yours

you guys have some insecurity/self-esteem issues if someone's opinion upsets you

Would me always agreeing with people make me more entertaining? I'm good at compliance, still; if we took some sort of poll and everyone agreed to it, I could completely revert back to childhood. Would you like that?

Would me always agreeing with people make me more entertaining? I'm good at compliance, still; if we took some sort of poll, I could completely revert back to childhood. Would you like that?

Um...I'm not trying to change you. Don't do anything for me. I don't know why you got all upset in the first place, I was just joking and apparently you didn't think I was. I don't think you should be compliant or anything, I just observed a change. And I think it is humorous. So shoot me. Sorry you got so upset.

And kl0p, I know you don't care about me. I believe your attitude said that from the get-go.

Yes.

I think kl0pper meant me when he said the thing about hating personas, but...yeah.

And I didn't get the joke. My bad. I get snappy this time of night.

I think kl0pper meant me when he said the thing about hating personas, but...yeah.

And I didn't get the joke. My bad. I get snappy this time of night.

It's okay. I just want to be friends

Like I said, I noticed that you changed on the forums, I didn't want to say anything, but then you made fun of yourself and I found it humorous. Sorry for the mix up.

Cheers.

Back to topic: I want to hear this song, despite the thrashing. Although Evanescence is an okay band covering an awesome band with awesome lyrics, but I do like her voice. She's probably an opera singer who couldn't cut it (ala Save Ferris). Yeah, I don't like judging things I haven't experienced.

I wasnt joking.
I think you're a bitch.

I still think you're a bastard. Settled?

I don't particularly like Evansecence. And I just somehow think it's too soon for a band like this to be covering Nirvana, of all things. I don't know why I think this. I'm not very coherent right now.

Then go to bed and quit whining.

i was referring to jane s
i didnt mind diabetic untill now
he/shes whiny

He is whiny. Diabetic is a dude.

Why am I whiny again?

too soon? too soon after He died?

I like the way you insidiously capitalized the h, very clever.

And yes, I think there should be some kind of minimum statute of limitations on how long it has to be before you can cover a song of a defunct band/singer. 15 years would be nice.

Ok, you have taken it too far, jane. This is music. It is art. I believe in freedom to do whatever you please in art. I could cover Lithium with sounds eminating from my anus and it would be music. Censorship sucks.

I think she means too soon for Evanescence, like they are too young of a band. I don't think she was talking about Him.

I did mean too soon for Evanescence, as well. But my thing about there being a minimum amount of time, I don't really want that to happen, I just think it would be nice. I also think that human beings should have to get lisences to breed, but you don't see me out there actually trying to put this into action.

if thats not the worst kind of hero worship i donno what is
hes dead, so what the fuck what?
just about every band thats been popular since 93 has ripped off nirvana, which was a ripoff band itself, so whats the big deal?

Ripoff of what, praytell?

nirvana? ripped off melvins big time. BIG time. ripped off big black and butthole surfers and the wipers and flipper and on and on and on. he didnt come up with anything new, just combined ideas of music he liked together and made it easier to swallow.

I agree with everyone here and everyone who hasn't posted here.

Love me, damnit.

forgot the all importan pixies kl0p

You think everything is a ripoff of the fucking Melvins. Whatever. No they're not.

yeah pixies. goddam did they ripoff the pixies.

melvins fucking invented grunge. everyone rips off grunge.

Hasn't this been out for months and months? It's not new by any means.

[QUOTE][i]Originally posted by kl0pper [/i]
[B]nirvana? ripped off melvins big time. BIG time. ripped off big black and butthole surfers and the wipers and flipper and on and on and on. he didnt come up with anything new, just combined ideas of music he liked together and made it easier to swallow. [/B][/QUOTE]

Flipper is horrible. I saved up a week's worth of allowance to buy their tape. Still pissed about that even 11 years after. I think that was the last time I bought music by word of mouth.