Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

tom9d
Level 12 Paladin +32 Broadsword
tom9d's picture
Posts: 3139
Joined: 2007-02-20
From: Misty Thicket

So I used to love In Flames.  They kicked ass in all the ways a band should kick ass.  Then they abruptly started sucking.  Literally...they had this album called Clayman which was great, and then their next album was a piece of shit called Reroute to Remain.  Then they put out another shitty album called Soundtrack to your escape.  I gave up on them.  They may have even put out a third shitty album...I'm not sure.  That's how angry I got. 

 

But then suddenly, this week, I find out that their last two albums are really good again!  This never happens!  What a lovely surprise!  In fact, there's one song I can't get out of my head and am totally in love with.

 

So you...what bands did you used to love before they turned to shit but now you love them again?



Spunck
Spunck's picture
Posts: 407
Joined: 2008-08-08
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

Well, I listened to Pink Floyd alot and then I got their album The Final Cut. That album would always depress me. They didn't turn shitty, I just didn't like the depression. So, I stopped listening to them for a while. A couple weeks or so. Then I got back into them, after I went to a value village by where I used to live and found a record for two dollars...

 

That record was The Wall.



Ironman
bros b4 hoes
Ironman's picture
Posts: 1560
Joined: 2007-04-09
From: In my own twisted mind
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

Tom, have you been sniffing glue again?

__________________________

IRONMAN is friend of the evil.



nathaniel parker
That's no moon!
nathaniel parker's picture
Posts: 19410
Joined: 2005-06-24
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

Well, Guns N Roses have fulfilled the first two parts of the thread, so here's hoping they'll eventually come around to the third part...

__________________________

Oh Jar Jar, every one hates you but me.



ejrathke
level 3 Spacemonkey
ejrathke's picture
Posts: 1906
Joined: 2008-02-08
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

guns n roses were never good.

i'll say the red hot chili peppers though. started cool, sucked for a while, and are now awesome again but for different reasons.

__________________________

IF I CATCH A DISEASE, YALL IS GONNA BE THE FIRST TO KNOW ABOUT IT
-xec8
http://cooleddy.wordpress.com/



rainbowsheeps
Manly Man Extraordinaire
rainbowsheeps's picture
Posts: 704
Joined: 2008-05-23
From: new york
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

Offspring was the first band I really listened to, but then I got tired of them. A lot. Too many joke songs and not enough goodness on their albums. Then their newest album, Rise and Fall, Rage and Grace is fucking wicked. Kicks most of their other album's asses.

__________________________

I am the ghost that haunts my dreams. It's pathetic, really, to be the monster of my own nightmares. Next to you is the only time I feel safe...

[ click! ]



Alecia
Bedazzled
Alecia's picture
Posts: 527
Joined: 2004-01-30
From: Frolix-8
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

New Kids on the Block. :D

 

I always thought Offspring's music sounded like stuff that had already been recorded by other artists. 



nathaniel parker
That's no moon!
nathaniel parker's picture
Posts: 19410
Joined: 2005-06-24
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

ejrathke wrote:

guns n roses were never good.

you're out of your gourd!

__________________________

Oh Jar Jar, every one hates you but me.



rainbowsheeps
Manly Man Extraordinaire
rainbowsheeps's picture
Posts: 704
Joined: 2008-05-23
From: new york
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

Alecia wrote:

New Kids on the Block. :D

 

I always thought Offspring's music sounded like stuff that had already been recorded by other artists. 

Hah. THat's an interesting way to look at it. But they're definitely "their own" sound. Punk with heavy rock influences, infusion of some Middle Eastern riffs, joke songs, some Spanish lyrics thrown in for good measure... their album Smash I liked a lot, it was very dark, then their stuff got lighter and lighter in tone. This newest album, though, is just really great. Sounds very different than most of their previous stuff.

__________________________

I am the ghost that haunts my dreams. It's pathetic, really, to be the monster of my own nightmares. Next to you is the only time I feel safe...

[ click! ]



ejrathke
level 3 Spacemonkey
ejrathke's picture
Posts: 1906
Joined: 2008-02-08
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

rainbowsheeps wrote:

Alecia wrote:

New Kids on the Block. :D

 

I always thought Offspring's music sounded like stuff that had already been recorded by other artists. 

Hah. THat's an interesting way to look at it. But they're definitely "their own" sound. Punk with heavy rock influences, infusion of some Middle Eastern riffs, joke songs, some Spanish lyrics thrown in for good measure... their album Smash I liked a lot, it was very dark, then their stuff got lighter and lighter in tone. This newest album, though, is just really great. Sounds very different than most of their previous stuff.

i think this is the most glowing interpretation of the offsprings music ever. because, really, other than this, id have to agree with alecia but go on to say that the offspring was not only never good, but is quite possibly a damaging band for the american music scene. though, thankfully, theyre fittingly unremembered.

__________________________

IF I CATCH A DISEASE, YALL IS GONNA BE THE FIRST TO KNOW ABOUT IT
-xec8
http://cooleddy.wordpress.com/



Smartazboy
No one flinches as we all float face down.
Smartazboy's picture
Posts: 13180
Joined: 2004-10-03
From: the burglar side of the bed.
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

rainbowsheeps wrote:

Offspring was the first band I really listened to, but then I got tired of them. A lot. Too many joke songs and not enough goodness on their albums. Then their newest album, Rise and Fall, Rage and Grace is fucking wicked. Kicks most of their other album's asses.

I've heard some of the new stuff and I like it. I was thinking of this band earlier, but I didn't say anything because I don't think they're awesome but they are pretty good.

__________________________

copsmiley



ejrathke
level 3 Spacemonkey
ejrathke's picture
Posts: 1906
Joined: 2008-02-08
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

nathaniel parker wrote:

ejrathke wrote:

guns n roses were never good.

you're out of your gourd!

i'll give slash a thumbs up for gusto at least

__________________________

IF I CATCH A DISEASE, YALL IS GONNA BE THE FIRST TO KNOW ABOUT IT
-xec8
http://cooleddy.wordpress.com/



nathaniel parker
That's no moon!
nathaniel parker's picture
Posts: 19410
Joined: 2005-06-24
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

ejrathke wrote:

rainbowsheeps wrote:

Alecia wrote:

New Kids on the Block. :D

 

I always thought Offspring's music sounded like stuff that had already been recorded by other artists. 

Hah. THat's an interesting way to look at it. But they're definitely "their own" sound. Punk with heavy rock influences, infusion of some Middle Eastern riffs, joke songs, some Spanish lyrics thrown in for good measure... their album Smash I liked a lot, it was very dark, then their stuff got lighter and lighter in tone. This newest album, though, is just really great. Sounds very different than most of their previous stuff.

i think this is the most glowing interpretation of the offsprings music ever. because, really, other than this, id have to agree with alecia but go on to say that the offspring was not only never good, but is quite possibly a damaging band for the american music scene. though, thankfully, theyre fittingly unremembered.

every 5-10 years Pretty Fly for a White Guy will pop up on one of those VH1 Hey! Remember the 90's specials.

__________________________

Oh Jar Jar, every one hates you but me.



rainbowsheeps
Manly Man Extraordinaire
rainbowsheeps's picture
Posts: 704
Joined: 2008-05-23
From: new york
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

ejrathke wrote:

rainbowsheeps wrote:

Alecia wrote:

New Kids on the Block. :D

 

I always thought Offspring's music sounded like stuff that had already been recorded by other artists. 

Hah. THat's an interesting way to look at it. But they're definitely "their own" sound. Punk with heavy rock influences, infusion of some Middle Eastern riffs, joke songs, some Spanish lyrics thrown in for good measure... their album Smash I liked a lot, it was very dark, then their stuff got lighter and lighter in tone. This newest album, though, is just really great. Sounds very different than most of their previous stuff.

i think this is the most glowing interpretation of the offsprings music ever. because, really, other than this, id have to agree with alecia but go on to say that the offspring was not only never good, but is quite possibly a damaging band for the american music scene. though, thankfully, theyre fittingly unremembered.

Fittingly unremembered... clearly, you don't know much about punk. Or maybe even rock. In the 90's, Green Day were sort of The Beatles of "pop-punk" and Offsprin were the Stones. Today, they're still very much alive, but their music hasn't been at the top of playlists for a while. They're still considered one of the best rock bands (at least in punk) in modern music though.

Personally, I haven't been a big fan for a long time. But their newest CD is quite good. And a lot of people have loved them for a long time. A couple of dorky singles aside like "Pretty Fly" and "Why Don't You Get a Job" (both off the same lackluster album), they have other great stuff: "Gone Away", "Smash", "Come Out and Play", "The Kids Aren't Alright" "Come Out Swinging" "Vultures" "The Meaning of Life" "Change the World" "All I Want" "Genocide" ... I could go on, but hey.

__________________________

I am the ghost that haunts my dreams. It's pathetic, really, to be the monster of my own nightmares. Next to you is the only time I feel safe...

[ click! ]



ejrathke
level 3 Spacemonkey
ejrathke's picture
Posts: 1906
Joined: 2008-02-08
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

i wouldnt say 'pop-punk' is punk.

and greenday has always sucked.

and who honestly considers them one of the best bands in modern music besides people who hate music?

__________________________

IF I CATCH A DISEASE, YALL IS GONNA BE THE FIRST TO KNOW ABOUT IT
-xec8
http://cooleddy.wordpress.com/



ejrathke
level 3 Spacemonkey
ejrathke's picture
Posts: 1906
Joined: 2008-02-08
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

i will say, though, that the kids arent alright was an enjoyable tune.

and double posts are cool.

__________________________

IF I CATCH A DISEASE, YALL IS GONNA BE THE FIRST TO KNOW ABOUT IT
-xec8
http://cooleddy.wordpress.com/



rainbowsheeps
Manly Man Extraordinaire
rainbowsheeps's picture
Posts: 704
Joined: 2008-05-23
From: new york
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

i'm not a fan of people that talk as if their opinions are fact: "green day has always sucked"

I like almost all of their albums. They used to be one of my favorite bands, and I've seen them live as well. I grew up with them. Millions of people also love them. Green Day, that is.

I don't really care if everyone likes Offspring or not, I wasn't a big fan for a long time either, but I also think it's idiotic to say they were damaging to American music. They were a punk band that happened to put out some dorky songs that got them even more well known, but their albums are typically filled with harder, more serious ones that have a lot to say. The Kids Aren't Alright, Come Out and Play, All I Want, Smash... all popular songs that tackle serious themes and do it well.

__________________________

I am the ghost that haunts my dreams. It's pathetic, really, to be the monster of my own nightmares. Next to you is the only time I feel safe...

[ click! ]



ejrathke
level 3 Spacemonkey
ejrathke's picture
Posts: 1906
Joined: 2008-02-08
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

i dont think fanbase determines how good something is

but you can like whatever you want

__________________________

IF I CATCH A DISEASE, YALL IS GONNA BE THE FIRST TO KNOW ABOUT IT
-xec8
http://cooleddy.wordpress.com/



bearchaser
Ï€
bearchaser's picture
Posts: 4811
Joined: 2006-03-03
From: Purgatorio
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

ejrathke wrote:

guns n roses were never good.

Id like to add U2 to that.

__________________________



ejrathke
level 3 Spacemonkey
ejrathke's picture
Posts: 1906
Joined: 2008-02-08
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

bearchaser wrote:

ejrathke wrote:

guns n roses were never good.

Id like to add U2 to that.

i second the motion

__________________________

IF I CATCH A DISEASE, YALL IS GONNA BE THE FIRST TO KNOW ABOUT IT
-xec8
http://cooleddy.wordpress.com/



Broken_Drum
F# A# ∞
Broken_Drum's picture
Posts: 72
Joined: 2008-08-10
From: Scratch
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

bearchaser wrote:

ejrathke wrote:

guns n roses were never good.

Id like to add U2 to that.

Throw in Metallica and Iron Maiden too while we're at it.



ejrathke
level 3 Spacemonkey
ejrathke's picture
Posts: 1906
Joined: 2008-02-08
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

dude, iron maiden, are you fucking serious?

the most metal band ever. ever.

thats fucking metal.

metallica was cool until '91. of course, i was only four at the time, but i mean the music they made.

__________________________

IF I CATCH A DISEASE, YALL IS GONNA BE THE FIRST TO KNOW ABOUT IT
-xec8
http://cooleddy.wordpress.com/



Broken_Drum
F# A# ∞
Broken_Drum's picture
Posts: 72
Joined: 2008-08-10
From: Scratch
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

ejrathke wrote:

dude, iron maiden, are you fucking serious?

Deadly.

ejrathke wrote:

the most metal band ever. ever.

I'm not really taken back by how "metal" they are.

ejrathke wrote:

thats fucking metal.

It's also fucking hideous.

 



ejrathke
level 3 Spacemonkey
ejrathke's picture
Posts: 1906
Joined: 2008-02-08
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

whatever, man.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N90h5f9Ulnk

metals awesome

__________________________

IF I CATCH A DISEASE, YALL IS GONNA BE THE FIRST TO KNOW ABOUT IT
-xec8
http://cooleddy.wordpress.com/



Broken_Drum
F# A# ∞
Broken_Drum's picture
Posts: 72
Joined: 2008-08-10
From: Scratch
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

I like Metal just never saw what the big thing was with IM, whatever floats your boat I guess.



Westontinople
Westontinople's picture
Posts: 702
Joined: 2006-05-11
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

 

[/quote]

Throw in Metallica and Iron Maiden too while we're at it.

[/quote]

 

wait, does that mean someone out there actually liked St. Anger?



ejrathke
level 3 Spacemonkey
ejrathke's picture
Posts: 1906
Joined: 2008-02-08
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

dude, iron maiden, are you fucking serious?

the most metal band ever. ever.

thats fucking metal.

metallica was cool until '91. of course, i was only four at the time, but i mean the music they made.

 

__________________________

IF I CATCH A DISEASE, YALL IS GONNA BE THE FIRST TO KNOW ABOUT IT
-xec8
http://cooleddy.wordpress.com/



spiritman
spiritman's picture
Posts: 69
Joined: 2007-09-14
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

sweet lord someone actually liked saint anger? I heard there were three or four guys, but I never thought I'd find one.

__________________________

"We sleep safely at night because rough men stand ready to visit violence on our behalf."-Winston Churchill



aphonicmessiah
the drunk hunter
aphonicmessiah's picture
Posts: 1501
Joined: 2007-01-03
From: somewhere. not here.
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

neil young

__________________________

love,
tom of the fjords



franc tireur
Baby Jaysus in Lederhosen
franc tireur's picture
Posts: 2647
Joined: 2003-04-25
From: Edo in the 1670s
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

Paul McCartney

__________________________



ejrathke
level 3 Spacemonkey
ejrathke's picture
Posts: 1906
Joined: 2008-02-08
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again
aphonicmessiah wrote:

neil young

havent listened to any of his stuff from, like, the last thirty[?] years.
how does his new stuff compare to, lets say, harvest moon? or other albums from that era.

__________________________

IF I CATCH A DISEASE, YALL IS GONNA BE THE FIRST TO KNOW ABOUT IT
-xec8
http://cooleddy.wordpress.com/



Mricpx
I'm not a ladies man, I'm a landmine
Mricpx's picture
Posts: 2017
Joined: 2007-05-28
From: 17237
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

I gotta say Linkin Park. I know it can be easily argued that they were never good, but I really loved their first album; Hybrid Theory. After that they put out one of the worst albums ever; Reanimation. After that was still shit with Meteora, but finally their newest album; Minutes to Midnight, which I haven't bought, but have heard a great deal from, seems to be at least decent. Their are a few songs from it that i really enjoy.



ejrathke
level 3 Spacemonkey
ejrathke's picture
Posts: 1906
Joined: 2008-02-08
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

i'll back linkin parks first album. probably more timing and my age at the time, but that album was soooooooooooooooo cool. though, i feel like if it came out now id hate it.

havent even heard a linkin park song since, probably, junior year[?], maybe longer.

__________________________

IF I CATCH A DISEASE, YALL IS GONNA BE THE FIRST TO KNOW ABOUT IT
-xec8
http://cooleddy.wordpress.com/



bassplr19
bassplr19's picture
Posts: 816
Joined: 2003-08-28
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again
ejrathke wrote:

guns n roses were never good.

i'll say the red hot chili peppers though. started cool, sucked for a while, and are now awesome again but for different reasons.

I'll agree with GnR, but the RHCP started good, got great, then started going downhill after Navarro left.

I think a lot of metal heads would put Machine Head in this category; their first couple albums were metal, then they tried two "nu-metal" albums, then came back fucking swinging hard with "Through Ashes.." and one of the best albums of 2007, "The Blackening"

__________________________

Think for yourself. Question Authority.



perfectblue20
perfectblue20's picture
Posts: 89
Joined: 2008-06-17
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

nada surf



lofivinyl
lofivinyl's picture
Posts: 3387
Joined: 2004-03-19
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

Bob Dylan

__________________________

How are you gentlemen! all your I have been belonging to busy to try the goulash that makes your country one for great justice and the record books.



nathaniel parker
That's no moon!
nathaniel parker's picture
Posts: 19410
Joined: 2005-06-24
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again
lofivinyl wrote:

Bob Dylan

good one except he's not a band.

__________________________

Oh Jar Jar, every one hates you but me.



nathaniel parker
That's no moon!
nathaniel parker's picture
Posts: 19410
Joined: 2005-06-24
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

what about bands that sucked, then got good, then went back to sucking again? hmmmm

__________________________

Oh Jar Jar, every one hates you but me.



lofivinyl
lofivinyl's picture
Posts: 3387
Joined: 2004-03-19
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

yeah well... i TRIED

__________________________

How are you gentlemen! all your I have been belonging to busy to try the goulash that makes your country one for great justice and the record books.



nathaniel parker
That's no moon!
nathaniel parker's picture
Posts: 19410
Joined: 2005-06-24
From:
Re: Bands that were awesome and then bad and then awesome again

now i feel bad for saying that.

__________________________

Oh Jar Jar, every one hates you but me.