Mac is NOT better!

3 replies jump to bottom
Chixulub
Granny Gear Artist
Chixulub's picture
From: East Coast of Kansas
Joined: 02/13/2004
User offline. Last seen 48 weeks 2 days ago.

Okay, so I'm at a job interview and the guy says they're mainly a Mac shop, but they have a couple of PCs for when jobs come in on a PC application, and he wants to know if I can handle a PC.

I'm like, well, yeah. I've worked on them as the primary machine for 16 years now. I've worked with Macs as well, we had both in my last job.

But then he's skeptical that I can handle a Mac. I point out that the applications are identical, with minor differences in font management. He still wasn't sure.

I pointed out that I've seen dozens of people who had never worked on the PC side hit the PCs at my former employer, and that it was a minor adjustment. Learning office procedures and the corporate culture is far harder.

Plus, I said, new software comes out every so often and makes beginners of us all. Operating systems revamp, or in the case of Pagemaker to InDesign, the application itself changes to a completely different setup, and the work still has to get done. If I couldn't learn this stuff quickly, I'd never have kept a job at all. For crying out loud, I learned to do this as a one-man art department in an office where no one had time to teach me anything.

I know it's unusual for an artist to be primarily familiar with the PC. Maybe even more for the PC to be preferred, but the main reason I prefer the PC is because it's familiar. Hire me to work on a Mac and in about 45 minutes I'll start getting used to it. Do anything 40 hours a week or more and it gets to be like breathing.

But the thing that struck me as oddest was his comment about the superiority of Macs. He asked me why my previous employer had leaned so heavily to the PC side. Economics, I said, they are cheaper. Plus, the IT guy we had was biased against Macs, so we weren't likely to have more of them than we needed. And once you have an archive of legacy files, you don't want to switch because the font issues and whatnot become pretty hairy. At least in a shop with a lot of repeat orders.

But he said, 'Well, yeah they're [I]cheaper[/I]. But Macs are better.'

I didn't correct him, but having worked with both, I can say he is wrong. Unless you define better as a pretty box and a lot more money for the same thing.

__________________________

When we call soccer 'football' the terrorists have won.

monkeywright
Joined: 12/05/2004
User offline. Last seen 12 weeks 1 day ago.

Hear hear! I'm so tired of these urban legends about Macs. "If you're doing graphics, you have to have a Mac"... why? "Better processor structure" uhhh "more speed"..."they're just built for graphics..."

Well, now they're both Intel based. As far as I've ever seen, as long as you're doing an apples to apples comparison (no pun intended), the results tend to be the same. One is a little faster than the other depending on the operation.

Everything that mac users used to deride PC users for (2 button mouse, Intel processors, etc) they now use. My dad is a Mac man since the little grey box era. I try to learn as much as I can abotu all systems.
Except Linux. Buncha weirdo penguin lovers.

Thus concludes my geeky rant from my recliner of rage.

Chixulub
Granny Gear Artist
Chixulub's picture
From: East Coast of Kansas
Joined: 02/13/2004
User offline. Last seen 48 weeks 2 days ago.

The Macs I've worked on didn't have two-button mice, but I've heard they exist. It pisses me off having to crawl around with the mouse for shit I should be able to right-click.

__________________________

When we call soccer 'football' the terrorists have won.

meatthinker
Aspergian, deal with it!
meatthinker's picture
From: your imagination
Joined: 05/19/2004
User offline. Last seen 2 years 42 weeks ago.

I am a registered penguin humper, posting this to you from a linux PC. With Mac OS 7-9, I used to think, [I]What kind of retarded OS is this where to run an application, you have to go to Recent Applications use Finder or browse the hard drive?[/I] Since OS X, navigation has improved, but it seems to me the only thing it really has going for it is a couple killer apps like Garage Band and the eye candy in the user interface. Also, the Mac guy looks to me like he doesn't bathe very often.

The part that annoys me about Macs is the hardware. You could have a stupid problem like a fan that is going bad. For a PC just go to CompUSA get another fan for $10 put it in and you're done. For a Mac, you might need a special tool to even get to where the fan is. I wonder if you could even get a Mac power supply, it's been a long time since I pulled apart a Mac though. I haven't pulled apart any Intel Macs yet, so maybe things will change (but I wouldn't count on it). Overall, if you like to tweak the hardware, Mac platform sucks, although I'm sure some Mac user would tell me, "you don't need to tweak the hardware because it's already so awesome."

__________________________

This is a really good idea.