2 logic mistakes?
1) Tyler tells Jack not to talk about him. But why isn't Jack surprised? He should not talk about Tyler with Marla for example. But Tyler f***s Marla. So she should know Tyler, could Jack think.
2) Bob asks Jack if he heard about Tyler. That Jack doesnt know about the other dates of Fight Club is clear (Tyler is there not Jack). But Bob should see that 'Cornelius' is Tyler. Or not?
I would guess, that its not about Marla not getting to know Tyler, which is totally senseless after they fcked. My impression was Tyler does not want Jack to tell her anything about him. If Jack would so Marla prolly would combine and see that the Tyler personality is just fake. This is a problem because Tyler loves Marla somehow.
The Bob story is somehow different. If i remember right Bob gets there after Tyler reads the fight club rules from the dark walking around the ring of men. So he probably never saw Tyler at all. Other explanation could be Tyler is not taking part in every meeting in every fight club all the time.
In a closed society where everybody's guilty, the only crime is getting caught. In a world of thieves, the only final sin is stupidity.
What Tyler wants is for people not to talk about him behind his back. The movie is pretty bad at explaining that, but the book is very clear about it. Hope that helps.
As for question #2, what Benny said: "Bob speaks as though he's never actually seen Tyler in the flesh."
Imagination is my religion.
and two more logical mistakes
1)ED NORTON is the narrator not JACK.
2)JACK is not even a character.
Chuck is a Muslim extremist!
thanks for sharing.blackhawk tactical pants.
— Spambot
"I could have done worse!" exultantly cried the murderer Lebret, sentenced at Rouen to hard labor for life. — Félix Fénéon
Chuck is a Muslim extremist!
I am Jack's raging religious beliefs. I strap 12 bricks of C4 to Jack. I sent jack flying in 35 different directions with 13 infidels.
This play is an affirmation of life—not an attempt to bring order out of chaos, nor to suggest improvements in creation, but simply to wake up to the very life we are living, which is so excellent once one gets one’s mind and desires out the way and lets it act of its own accord. -John Cage
1)ED NORTON is the narrator not JACK.
2)JACK is not even a character.
3) JACK is JOE!
THEN WHO WAS PHONE?!
Keyser Sose. Duh.
Tuffy the Dump Truck may rarely increase the risk of a heart attack or stroke. The risk may be greater if you have heart disease or increased risk for heart disease (for example, due to smoking, family history of heart disease, or conditions such as high blood pressure or diabetes), or with longer use. Tuffy should not be taken right before or after heart bypass surgery. Also, Tuffy may infrequently cause serious (rarely fatal) bleeding from the stomach or intestines. This effect can occur without warning symptoms at any time while taking Tuffy. Older adults may be at higher risk for this effect. (See also Precautions and Drug Interactions sections.) Stop taking Tuffy and get medical help right away if you notice any of the following rare but serious side effects: bloody or black/tarry stools, persistent stomach/abdominal pain, vomit that looks like coffee grounds, chest/jaw/left arm pain, shortness of breath, unusual sweating, weakness on one side of the body, sudden vision changes, slurred speech. Ask your doctor if Tuffy is right for you.
[QUOTE=freundchen;991818]1) Tyler tells Jack not to talk about him. But why isn't Jack surprised? He should not talk about Tyler with Marla for example. But Tyler f***s Marla. So she should know Tyler, could Jack think.
2) Bob asks Jack if he heard about Tyler. That Jack doesnt know about the other dates of Fight Club is clear (Tyler is there not Jack). But Bob should see that 'Cornelius' is Tyler. Or not?[/QUOTE]
1.) He is surprised... or, more confused about it at first. But he shrugs it off and just does what Tyler tells him to do, which is true to his character for most of the film. The force of Tyler's personality dominates Jack's behavior. Tyler is the alpha male, and Jack looks up to him, worships him in a way. Until, of course, at the end when Jack finally stands up to him.
Maybe that answers your question, maybe not. I didn't quite understand the sentence you wrote: "So she should know Tyler, could Jack think." Is there a typo in there somewhere? Can't make sense of it. Marla knows Jack as Tyler... she never meets him as Jack. The scene cuts away before he tells her his name while she's standing in the middle of the street. So all along, she thinks he's Tyler. If he starts talking about Tyler in the third person (as he does on one occasion when she comes over while members of PM are working in the garden and he's drinking Vodka from the bottle: "Tyler isn't here right now. Tyler went away. Tyler gone."), she might say something like "Why are you talking about yourself in the third person?" which could potentially flush Tyler out of his unconscious, which Tyler doesn't want.
Make sense?
2.) My assumption is that Tyler/Jack doesn't go on the same nights as Bob (until they decide to meet up and fight in the next scene.) Tyler doesn't need to be there for a Fight Club to take place.
Remember, he starts branches of them all over the country and then they basically run themselves. It's not a stretch to think he doesn't attend the original FC every night of the week. Also, Bob speaks as though he's never actually seen Tyler in the flesh. "Supposedly, he was born in a mental institution, and he sleeps only one hour a night. He's a great man. Do you know about Tyler Durden?"