Narrator's Name

66 replies jump to bottom
WallSt
Joined: 05/08/2008
User offline. Last seen 3 years 24 weeks ago.

So, I'm having an argument with a buddy about the Narrotor's name.

He thinks it is Jack.

I think he doens't have one.

He thinks IMDB is right.

I think the only way to know is to get the answer from Chuck. 

 

Is there a way to find any real documentation regarding the Narrator's possible name.

 

Thanks!

/sorry if this was posted before.  i'm at work and gotta make this quick!

Nightrious
Nightrious's picture
Joined: 11/10/2003
User offline. Last seen 16 hours 27 min ago.

Ted.

Smartazboy
Gimme your money, your life, or your bald-headed wife.
Smartazboy's picture
Joined: 10/03/2004
User is online

Theodore, actually.

__________________________
big S wrote:
Have a good one! I'd sing you happy birthday but the melody was written by a Sunday school teacher and i know how much you hate God so i won't sing to you. Have a good one though.

Police
Nightrious
Nightrious's picture
Joined: 11/10/2003
User offline. Last seen 16 hours 27 min ago.

Wasn't Theodore the man who owned the pub? Theodore's Pub? That sounds right.

_eNdLeSs_MiKe_
You're Everything I Thought I Never Wanted
_eNdLeSs_MiKe_'s picture
From: New York, Live, It's Saturday Night!
Joined: 07/23/2006
User offline. Last seen 10 hours 53 min ago.

In the movie he doesn't have a name. In the book his name is Joe.

__________________________
Tuffy wrote:
I first read that as

I LOVE FUCKING TREES

and I was pretty sure you were going to be stumped.

monkeywright
Joined: 12/05/2004
User offline. Last seen 2 weeks 2 days ago.

NO! His name is Joe in the engloish musical adaptation, but in the book he has no name. IMDB lists him as Jack, but only because Ed Norton insisted on a name other than "narrator" for the credits. Make some research.

luttleTinda245
luttleTinda245's picture
From: Louisville, Kentucky
Joined: 05/17/2005
User offline. Last seen 2 years 43 weeks ago.

Chloe? I thought of the narrator as Jack but is Tyler who is Chloe. It makes sense to me that Chloe is Tyler Durden. Isn't that who Tyler Durden was based off of, Chloe? So, actually I thought it was Chloe who is Tyler speaking through Jack.

__________________________

I have this dream life where I get to be a celebrity but I get to navigate the world fairly easily because I'm always in character. ~dana carvey

WallSt
Joined: 05/08/2008
User offline. Last seen 3 years 24 weeks ago.

double-post.

deleted.

WallSt
Joined: 05/08/2008
User offline. Last seen 3 years 24 weeks ago.

 

 

 

Ugh.  It almost seems like even asking here is a mistake.

In the movie, he reads stuff like "I am Jack's..." from the articles and then narrates them, to himself, and you hear him narrate it times later in the moive.  In the credits it is listed as Narrator.  It doesn't say Jack anywhere in the credits I've seen.  Sorry, guy who told someone to "[do] some research", but you should also.

In the book, he reads stuff like "I am Joe's..." from the articles and then narrates them, to himself, and you read what he is narrating to himself later in the book. When he confronts Marla about who he is he narrates things like "My parents know my real name". The Narrator never actually SAYS anything in the book as you would traditionally SAY anything in books (i.e., with quotes [" "]).

There is no way on God's green Earth that Chloe is anything more than a skeleton Meryl Streep. Tyler isn't anything involving that cancer victim. How is a man with all that muscle, brain, and charisma based off a dying woman? That is insane. Tyler is kinda like the "Id" of the narrator, the subconscious.

nathaniel parker
Every mile is two in winter.
nathaniel parker's picture
From: East North Pole
Joined: 06/23/2005
User offline. Last seen 10 weeks 3 days ago.

The narrator doesn't have a name in the book OR movie. They just switched it from Joe to Jack for the film because they couldn't get Reader's Digest to give them the rights to use the articles he reads from so they just changed the name.

WallSt
Joined: 05/08/2008
User offline. Last seen 3 years 24 weeks ago.

Thank you!

Synnove
Promise little and do much.
Synnove's picture
From: Columbia, SC
Joined: 10/25/2006
User offline. Last seen 2 years 22 weeks ago.

Nate, you've answered this question before, haven't you?

__________________________

Good coffee is like drinking Rock and Roll.

nathaniel parker
Every mile is two in winter.
nathaniel parker's picture
From: East North Pole
Joined: 06/23/2005
User offline. Last seen 10 weeks 3 days ago.

many, many times.

HunterNIU
Joined: 05/08/2008
User offline. Last seen 3 years 39 weeks ago.
The narrator doesn't have a name in the book OR movie.

I don't think it is to unreasonable to assume he [i]has[/i] a name.  He was probably given a name at birth or while being raised.  I'm sure his boss wouldn't hire him without a name. Also, in the book he says that his parents know his name.

"The absence of evidence is not the evidence of absence."
<Gin Rummy>

So just because his name was never flat out told to the reader as his name, nor told or shown (possibly on his driver's license or business card would have been a neat spot) to the viewer in the movie, does not mean that his name was not supposed to be Joe/Jack.

Maybe we as the readers and viewers are supposed to be clever enough to realize his name is Joe/Jack without indiscriminate proof of this fact. 

 

They just switched it from Joe to Jack for the film because they couldn't get Reader's Digest to give them the rights to use the articles he reads from so they just changed the name.

Am I understanding you correctly that they got around the rights by changing the name because the name (Joe) was part of a quote out of the article?  If so, wow that's really all you have to change for it not to be copywright infringement?  Wish I knew that in high school... :^Þ

 

nathaniel parker
Every mile is two in winter.
nathaniel parker's picture
From: East North Pole
Joined: 06/23/2005
User offline. Last seen 10 weeks 3 days ago.
HunterNIU wrote:
The narrator doesn't have a name in the book OR movie.

I don't think it is to unreasonable to assume he [i]has[/i] a name.  He was probably given a name at birth or while being raised.  I'm sure his boss wouldn't hire him without a name. Also, in the book he says that his parents know his name.

"The absence of evidence is not the evidence of absence."
<Gin Rummy>

So just because his name was never flat out told to the reader as his name, nor told or shown (possibly on his driver's license or business card would have been a neat spot) to the viewer in the movie, does not mean that his name was not supposed to be Joe/Jack.

Maybe we as the readers and viewers are supposed to be clever enough to realize his name is Joe/Jack without indiscriminate proof of this fact.

The narrator doesn't have a name ~~> [b][i]IN[/i][/b]<~~ the book or movie.

in the world of the book or movie, he is never given an actual name. Of course, it can be figured he does HAVE one, but it's never given.

 

They just switched it from Joe to Jack for the film because they couldn't get Reader's Digest to give them the rights to use the articles he reads from so they just changed the name.

Am I understanding you correctly that they got around the rights by changing the name because the name (Joe) was part of a quote out of the article?  If so, wow that's really all you have to change for it not to be copywright infringement?  Wish I knew that in high school... :^Þ

 

For the small amount they used the articles in the film, yeah, that's all they really needed to do. If they were going to use the entire article word for word, and use it over and over, they'd need to do a lot more than just change the name. If they were just going to use the line once and that was it they probably could get away with using the entire thing. But for the amount the did use it, (maybe 10 times throughout the film/book?) and just using the first line from it and not the entire article. Just changing the name does a lot to take away from them having to worry about a lawsuit later on.  They also did the same thing with the dynamite recipe.

nathaniel parker
Every mile is two in winter.
nathaniel parker's picture
From: East North Pole
Joined: 06/23/2005
User offline. Last seen 10 weeks 3 days ago.
nathaniel parker wrote:
HunterNIU wrote:
The narrator doesn't have a name in the book OR movie.

I don't think it is to unreasonable to assume he [i]has[/i] a name.  He was probably given a name at birth or while being raised.  I'm sure his boss wouldn't hire him without a name. Also, in the book he says that his parents know his name.

"The absence of evidence is not the evidence of absence."
<Gin Rummy>

So just because his name was never flat out told to the reader as his name, nor told or shown (possibly on his driver's license or business card would have been a neat spot) to the viewer in the movie, does not mean that his name was not supposed to be Joe/Jack.

Maybe we as the readers and viewers are supposed to be clever enough to realize his name is Joe/Jack without indiscriminate proof of this fact.

The narrator doesn't have a name ~~> [b][i]IN[/i][/b]<~~ the book or movie.

in the world of the book or movie, he is never given an actual name. Of course, it can be figured he does HAVE one, but it's never given.

 

They just switched it from Joe to Jack for the film because they couldn't get Reader's Digest to give them the rights to use the articles he reads from so they just changed the name.
Quote:
Am I understanding you correctly that they got around the rights by changing the name because the name (Joe) was part of a quote out of the article?  If so, wow that's really all you have to change for it not to be copywright infringement?  Wish I knew that in high school... :^Þ

 

For the small amount they used the articles in the film, yeah, that's all they really needed to do. If they were going to use the entire article word for word, and use it over and over, they'd need to do a lot more than just change the name. If they were just going to use the line once and that was it they probably could get away with using the entire thing. But for the amount the did use it, (maybe 10 times throughout the film/book?) and just using the first line from it and not the entire article. Just changing the name does a lot to take away from them having to worry about a lawsuit later on.  They also did the same thing with the dynamite recipe.
monkeywright
Joined: 12/05/2004
User offline. Last seen 2 weeks 2 days ago.

I think I know a little more about this than any of you. Make some research!

 
I'm so happy someone on this thread took my post seriously. Mayhem!
HunterNIU
Joined: 05/08/2008
User offline. Last seen 3 years 39 weeks ago.
monkeywright wrote:

I think I know a little more about this than any of you. Make some research!

 

What the hell does "make some research" mean?  Like make up research and pretend its real?

monkeywright
Joined: 12/05/2004
User offline. Last seen 2 weeks 2 days ago.

What kinds of question his these? You are not from the Cult for very long! Make some rreserch or the he-she will come for you!

franc tireur
What's the rumpus ?
franc tireur's picture
From: The Big City in the 1920s
Joined: 04/25/2003
User is online

I like this thread, reminds me of the good old days.

__________________________

Jefferson
Joined: 05/12/2008
User offline. Last seen 3 years 37 weeks ago.

 I Can't help but think Chuck didn't give the narrator a name just to see how much people would fuss over what the guy should be called, or argue over what his name really is when you look at all the "clues". His name is not of importance (kinda like the suit case in Pulp Fiction with what was in it). But his symbolism and meaning is so important, that it seems unbearable to not refer to him with a name, rather "the narrator". Hell, if you really need him to have a name that bad, call him whatever you want. I like calling him Dave.

 - Jefferson

franc tireur
What's the rumpus ?
franc tireur's picture
From: The Big City in the 1920s
Joined: 04/25/2003
User is online

In the french version his name is Jean-Claude, Tyler is Louis and Marla is Claudine.

__________________________

nathaniel parker
Every mile is two in winter.
nathaniel parker's picture
From: East North Pole
Joined: 06/23/2005
User offline. Last seen 10 weeks 3 days ago.
Jefferson wrote:

His name is not of importance (kinda like the suit case in Pulp Fiction with what was in it).

That's called a [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macguffin]MacGuffin[/url]. Hitchcock loved 'em.
Mexicreatin
Practically Perfect in Everyway
Mexicreatin's picture
From: Sacramento, CA
Joined: 07/27/2007
User offline. Last seen 20 weeks 6 days ago.

i honestly never noticed that he doesnt have a name in the book or the movie till these threads about it.

__________________________

i'm a terrible person, in more ways than one.

Jefferson
Joined: 05/12/2008
User offline. Last seen 3 years 37 weeks ago.

Thanks dude,  I always wanted to know what that was called. =D

MrRantCasey
Joined: 02/25/2008
User offline. Last seen 3 years 10 weeks ago.

 Well, there is theory that he doesn't have a name, or is name could be Tyler Durden, even Marla calls him Tyler. I don't know? Only Chuck knows haha! 

 

In Russia
Joined: 11/11/2008
User offline. Last seen 1 year 38 weeks ago.

Chapter 21

"Only in death will we have our own names since only in death are we no longer part of the effort. In death we become heroes."

No name, because the narrator is everyman.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Everyman

Gods-Dandruff
Joined: 10/11/2009
User offline. Last seen 2 years 16 weeks ago.

His name is Vladimir Ghirlandaio.

lullaby
Joined: 11/03/2009
User offline. Last seen 50 weeks 4 days ago.
In Russia wrote:
Chapter 21

"Only in death will we have our own names since only in death are we no longer part of the effort. In death we become heroes."

No name, because the narrator is everyman.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Everyman

That's true. I must agree with you.

Total Backline
Joined: 03/18/2010
User offline. Last seen 30 weeks 6 days ago.

i'm sure it's stated somewhere in the audio commentary for the movie that ed norton was told the actual name of the narrator by chuck himself. or chuck might have simply told ed that there was no name.

Girlslikecultstoo
Joined: 11/23/2010
User offline. Last seen 1 year 10 weeks ago.

Does it actually matter what his name is? i think it gives it more edge that we don't know his name. As he can be anyone. Even you. Let's not know or even guess his name. Allow him to be whoever you wish him to be.

Tuffy
Nec Spe...
Tuffy's picture
From: ...Nec Metu.
Joined: 03/29/2009
User offline. Last seen 32 min 26 sec ago.
Girlslikecultstoo wrote:
Does it actually matter what his name is?

No.
Girlslikecultstoo wrote:
i think it gives it more edge that we don't know his name. As he can be anyone. Even you.

Well sure, as a literary device. The Narrator is Everyman. Rather, Anyman.
Girlslikecultstoo wrote:
Let's not know or even guess his name.

Stifling theory and analysis is counterproductive however As a species, we label and classify. We need to define - even the indefinable - thus the discussion above. Inquiry never harms.
Girlslikecultstoo wrote:
Allow him to be whoever you wish him to be.

In order for that to take place, one would have to first decide who one wishes the Narrator to be.
__________________________

"Tuffy, you're a Dalek, but only because you're only being kept alive by metal, science and hatred." - ScubaSteve1729

Girlslikecultstoo
Joined: 11/23/2010
User offline. Last seen 1 year 10 weeks ago.

Clearly Tuffy, i've got you interested in what the narrative's name might be. We have no idea who these people are on this website and yet, we repily to one another in order to know more about them. I like the ide aof 'I' as i am 'I' or anyone else for that matter. Like, i have no idea if your male or female and it really doesn't matter. we can be whoever we want as the cyber world allows to be so. How's that for pause for thought?

xec8
Godder than God
xec8's picture
From: The Pearly Gates
Joined: 04/26/2005
User offline. Last seen 16 hours 49 min ago.
Girlslikecultstoo wrote:
How's that for pause for thought?

Not very good, actually.
__________________________

thanks for sharing.blackhawk tactical pants.
— Spambot

"I could have done worse!" exultantly cried the murderer Lebret, sentenced at Rouen to hard labor for life. — Félix Fénéon

Tuffy
Nec Spe...
Tuffy's picture
From: ...Nec Metu.
Joined: 03/29/2009
User offline. Last seen 32 min 26 sec ago.
Girlslikecultstoo wrote:
Clearly Tuffy, i've got you interested in what the narrative's name might be.

No, not at all, actually.
__________________________

"Tuffy, you're a Dalek, but only because you're only being kept alive by metal, science and hatred." - ScubaSteve1729

Girlslikecultstoo
Joined: 11/23/2010
User offline. Last seen 1 year 10 weeks ago.

Oh that's a shame. i thought i was on to something. I will have to think of something else.

So why bother all of you on here wanting to know what the name of the narrative is???? I don't give a fuck. I like a little mystery.

Tuffy
Nec Spe...
Tuffy's picture
From: ...Nec Metu.
Joined: 03/29/2009
User offline. Last seen 32 min 26 sec ago.
Girlslikecultstoo wrote:
I don't give a fuck. I like a little mystery.

This is contradictory.

You don't like mystery, you prefer ignorance. Which is fine. They just aren't the same thing. Mystery requires an interest in discovery and resolution.

__________________________

"Tuffy, you're a Dalek, but only because you're only being kept alive by metal, science and hatred." - ScubaSteve1729

Tuffy
Nec Spe...
Tuffy's picture
From: ...Nec Metu.
Joined: 03/29/2009
User offline. Last seen 32 min 26 sec ago.

Also, you keep saying "narrative" when you mean (presumably) "narrator". Is English not your first language? We can simplify the discussion if need be.

__________________________

"Tuffy, you're a Dalek, but only because you're only being kept alive by metal, science and hatred." - ScubaSteve1729

Tuffy
Nec Spe...
Tuffy's picture
From: ...Nec Metu.
Joined: 03/29/2009
User offline. Last seen 32 min 26 sec ago.

And, in answer to the original post, in the context of the book and the film, the protagonist/narrator is never named. He refers to himself as "Joe"/"Jack" as a narrative device, but that is all. His identity is unknowable.

__________________________

"Tuffy, you're a Dalek, but only because you're only being kept alive by metal, science and hatred." - ScubaSteve1729

RidingADeadHorse
a dude
RidingADeadHorse's picture
From: over there
Joined: 05/28/2008
User offline. Last seen 32 weeks 3 days ago.

i'm pretty sure his name is chuck.

but i gotta think about this after i smoke an R.J. Reynolds with my Marcel Bich. then i'm gonna ask some people on Mark Zuckerberg with my Bill Gates.

Tuffy
Nec Spe...
Tuffy's picture
From: ...Nec Metu.
Joined: 03/29/2009
User offline. Last seen 32 min 26 sec ago.

I'd ask how that's working out for you, but I can see that it isn't.

__________________________

"Tuffy, you're a Dalek, but only because you're only being kept alive by metal, science and hatred." - ScubaSteve1729

Girlslikecultstoo
Joined: 11/23/2010
User offline. Last seen 1 year 10 weeks ago.

Why are you so mean????????

Noahrm23
Just one more beer then grow up.
Noahrm23's picture
From: Portlandish
Joined: 02/23/2010
User offline. Last seen 2 days 22 hours ago.
Girlslikecultstoo wrote:
Why are you so mean????????

Mean, for Tuffy this is nice. He just doesn't deal with Silly bullshit, unless he's causing it. Read through most any post in this place and realize that most people around this site dont like dealing with people trying to be philosophical about names and events that really dont matter. When they try to sound smart, by spouting off random bits and phrases, that's when people, Like Tuffy, and half the other regular posters start up. It also helps to not take yourself, and anyone else hear too serious. I have been insulted and hazed quite a bit but as long as you don't act like a little girl with a skinned knee about it, things will work out. I'm not saying that you, Girlslikecultstoo, are doing these things. This is just a general reminder.
And to be fair Tuffy here is just posting his responses and feelings towards your statements, just as you respond to his.
So understand that the people around here are not mean, there just having there fun, you get used to it.

Also we all know his name was Herman Pettycloth.

Tuffy
Nec Spe...
Tuffy's picture
From: ...Nec Metu.
Joined: 03/29/2009
User offline. Last seen 32 min 26 sec ago.

__________________________

"Tuffy, you're a Dalek, but only because you're only being kept alive by metal, science and hatred." - ScubaSteve1729

Girlslikecultstoo
Joined: 11/23/2010
User offline. Last seen 1 year 10 weeks ago.

for a woman, i have pretty hard skin. I just felt This tuffy guy had it in for me. I just joined this group for research as i'm studying fight club for English. Looking at what drives men of today to read these sort of books. I've come up with the idea that its to do with the lack of his father within the book. He goes on and on about it.

Thanks for your comment though.

audreythirteen
Lick the barrel of my gun once I'm done just so I can feel again
audreythirteen's picture
From: City of Dreams
Joined: 05/12/2009
User offline. Last seen 4 hours 47 min ago.
Girlslikecultstoo wrote:
for a woman, i have pretty hard skin. I just felt This tuffy guy had it in for me. I just joined this group for research as i'm studying fight club for English. Looking at what drives men of today to read these sort of books. I've come up with the idea that its to do with the lack of his father within the book. He goes on and on about it.

Thanks for your comment though.

hard or thick skin? Also I doubt that's why men read Chuck's books and men aren't the only demographic that read Chuck's books. And why would a lack of father be why men read Chuck's books. Sorry if it seems I'm giving you a hard time but I'm really curious as to what your overall argument is.

__________________________
Nightrious wrote:

"Everyday takes figuring out all over again how to fuckin live."

Tuffy
Nec Spe...
Tuffy's picture
From: ...Nec Metu.
Joined: 03/29/2009
User offline. Last seen 32 min 26 sec ago.

God forbid I answer the question. Has a woman skin like pudding.

The babelfish gag is painfully obvious, btw.

__________________________

"Tuffy, you're a Dalek, but only because you're only being kept alive by metal, science and hatred." - ScubaSteve1729

matthew.odonnell
The Fist Typist
matthew.odonnell's picture
From: Down Undaaaaaah!
Joined: 07/07/2009
User offline. Last seen 1 week 4 days ago.

Oh, boy.

__________________________
Tuffy wrote:
If I'm fucking you, it's because I want to merge my soul with yours; regain, however briefly, the divine unity that was lost when we descended from glory and manifested into these clumsy flawed sexes.
ScribblingDes
Fuck Pants
ScribblingDes's picture
From: louisiana
Joined: 02/16/2007
User offline. Last seen 9 hours 47 min ago.

I must be jaded, because I really don't think Tuffy is mean. Just honest.

__________________________

"after feeling under the weather a few days one time I went to check my symptoms online. web MD informed me I had Scarlet Fever." -Cam Cam

"I think I got hit on too. An 80-year-old woman said my glasses are very attractive. I told her that hers were pretty nice too.". -Steve

"Bloke came home from work and I'm still in my nightie. I call that a successful day off." --Sarah

matthew.odonnell
The Fist Typist
matthew.odonnell's picture
From: Down Undaaaaaah!
Joined: 07/07/2009
User offline. Last seen 1 week 4 days ago.

He's not mean. Funny, on the other hand.

__________________________
Tuffy wrote:
If I'm fucking you, it's because I want to merge my soul with yours; regain, however briefly, the divine unity that was lost when we descended from glory and manifested into these clumsy flawed sexes.
Noahrm23
Just one more beer then grow up.
Noahrm23's picture
From: Portlandish
Joined: 02/23/2010
User offline. Last seen 2 days 22 hours ago.

I saw him kick a puppy once, but the puppy was biting a baby. SO how does that work?