My first short story- Advice needed.

11 replies jump to bottom
Barca Boy
Mes Que Un Cultista
Barca Boy's picture
From: Barcelona I wish
Joined: 07/22/2006
User offline. Last seen 18 hours 11 min ago.

I've started a Creative Writing Course and for the next Module I have to submit a Short Story. I've dug up my story from the Trainstation Anthology and I need some advice and criticism from you guys.

Its the first writing Ive done since I left school, its very rough and also semi autobiographical so any help you can give me would be great.

 

Untitled

When I woke up this morning the first thing I thought was I need a drink. Now it doesn't seem like such a good idea. It's snowing outside and the only way to keep warm is knocking back this cheap whiskey. The Whiteport trainstation is the easiest place in town to spend the night. The nightwatchman knows me by now. According to the news it's Monday January the 13th and this bad weather wont let up for a while. Some kid in a highschool went nuts with a gun and reduced the overcrwding in public schooling. In other news a dog gave birth to kittens in Brazil.

 

They say alcohol will remove any stain you come across, for me it removed everything, my wife, my job my house and car. But I'm getting ahead of myself.

 

My Mother died while giving birth to me nand since then my Father has never forgiven me. There were three of us in the house, me, my Dad and his anger. You could light up Vegas with all his pent up rage. To help matters I was the quietest kid in school. I thought tha everytime I did something wrong I would get beaten but even the bullies weren't that malicious.

 

When I was twelve I took my first drink. All my problems and insecurities went away. Most people don't like their, a bit like their first cigarette but to me it tasted divine, like sweet nectar. I was hooked and drank myself through adolescence, one pitfall after another. By fourteen I had progressed to spirits and soon gave up my interest in sports. Never being big or tough enough for Football I played a little soccer but that won't get you any luck with cheerleaders. I finished highschool almost top of my class and got accepted into a college in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, to study Law like so many other Mc Donalds staff. On first arriving on campus it seemed that my feelings of low confidence and poor self-belief couldn't cross borders and were left behind. I was grateful to find a place where I could start over again, lay a new foundation and rebuild my directionless life. Little did I know that eventually that self-doubt would slip security and catch up with me?

 

When I was first introuced to Cocaine I shyly shook its hand, keeping my distance but curiuos of my new acquaintance. As it progressed I started to grasp it with both hands never failing to express my gratitude of seeing my best friend again. One line of that white powder and I was on an escaltor goin up towards optimism and a floor full of confidence and energy. Unfortunately, I didn't forget to visit te depression department on the way down.

 

The only good thing that came out of my further education was meeting Molly. How could a guy with Irish blood not love a girl called Molly? Behind every good man is a good woman but in my case no matter how good a woman she still couldn't cure me. Swearing I wouldn't drink again was followed by a week long bender accompanied by nosebleeds and permanent shakes. Miraculously I graduated towards the bottom and I made a promise to get help.

 

On April the first eighteen years ago I checked into a reputable psychiatric hospital and began the twelve steps of recovery. My life got back together until January the thirteenth 1991, a man who was laid off at the factory in town decided to stop off in a local bar for a few drinks and careened into her head on, wiping out the best thing in my life instantly. At least she didn't suffer. I was almost fifteen years sober and once again alcohol had become the lowest common denominator in my life.

 

NowI live here at the station where a few months ago they decided to start playing classical music over the PA to give us lowlifes a bit of culture. Jimmy my mate wil be along shortly and we can see what he made from begging. Everyday he sits by the post office with his legs tucked in pretnding to be a Vietnam vet. The farthest East he's ever been is New Jersey. In his youth he was a promising baseball player and even had trials with Chicago but I reckon it was more like;y he was on trial in Chicago. We go in seperate directions and search the payphones and vending machines for spare change. Jimmy's a good guy whose life went down the tubes around ten years before my downfall. I used to pass him on the street and throw him an odd bit of change. His opening line was "Can you spare a kidney? If not, a dollar will do". He often remembers people's faces so it makes them harder to pass without them giving him something. He's been panhandling a lot than me and has become a bit of an expert at it. Back in Chicago where, where he's from he was a grifter. He read the obituaries everyday and a few days after a funeral would present a bill to the deceased wife for a load of dirty magazines. The widow not wanting other people to know about it would pay up out of embarrassment until he tried it on a blindmans wife. Going into the kitchen to get her pocketbook she returned with a shotgun and he was too afraid to try it since.

 

After I lost everything I resorted to helping women push their trolleys from the Suoermarket until I was told to get lost by security once too often. I never had the brains or balls to be a grifter.

 

We spend the night watching the news cahnnelover and over again. As each hour passes the death toll from the highschool shooting increases steadily. Students pour their hearts out on TV while admitting there was always someting funny about that psycho. The obligatory Congressman arrives to denounce Stephen King and Marilynn Manson. At 9:20 pm his English teacher comments that his favourite novel was Catcher in the Rye. 9:40 and the NRA announce an upcoming rally before the funerals are over.

 

By now the cafe is closed and we can rummage through the bins for some craps. There is enough food to keep us two from spending on anything other than alcohol. We used to go to the back of the local Mc Donald's until they started pouring bleach in the bins.

 

Let me tell you about Molly, she was a sweeheart and stuck by me through thick and thin. I always knew I wouldn't survive without he. We were married one month after I left Rehab. My advisor warned me not to make any major decisions but there was no stopping us. Young in love and invincible, that was us. I miss her so much its untrue, a feeling in the pit of my stomach that just wont go away. Sometimes I think of other things but any little reminder is a ammerblow to the chest. Time heals everything but the scars remain.

 

I think I've had enough of this miserable existence. I go through this every night but tonight I think I'm going places. The 11:30 from Columbus to Trenton passes straight through and doesn't stop. I think I'm going to go see my wife.

 

 

 

_eNdLeSs_MiKe_
You're Everything I Thought I Never Wanted
_eNdLeSs_MiKe_'s picture
From: New York, Live, It's Saturday Night!
Joined: 07/23/2006
User offline. Last seen 1 hour 55 min ago.

I enjoyed this. If I don't, I don't read to the end.

I really like how it's like a story that you order some drinks for a guy in a bar after he tells it.

The only real problem that stuck out for me was spelling/grammar and the like.

My advice, read some of Chuck's monthly essays on writing.

You might even want to try switching the order of some paragraphs to see how that works out.

Good stuff, mate.

__________________________
Tuffy wrote:
I first read that as

I LOVE FUCKING TREES

and I was pretty sure you were going to be stumped.

Odegrar
Odegrar's picture
Joined: 02/29/2008
User offline. Last seen 3 years 1 week ago.

Nice work!

It's fun and entertaining.

Have fun with the story.

Is this the only way u can tell it? Or can you think of anything else?

Try re-arranging the order of the scenes, change words in sentences to see if the effect u want is boostered or diminished.

After a while u'll come to the final shape. That is, the story u  can't touch without ruinning it.

Congrats on your first story, Barça Boy!

Hustle Charlie
I'm trying to see the future in a tea cup and a saucer
Hustle Charlie's picture
From: Bay Area, CA
Joined: 12/09/2007
User offline. Last seen 3 years 32 weeks ago.

First things last:

I was there; with my dad, with the bottle, in the bag, in the station...going to Trenton.

My attention was held throughout and thoroughly enjoyed reading this.

Now somebody(s) will come below me and bring their McDonald's law degree and shoe polish and help you with grammar/spelling/opinions.  Remember--garbage in, garbage out.

I can see you becoming a Big Mac and Fries Derek.

__________________________

In this league, sportsmanship is for old liberals and young fools.

monkeywright
Joined: 12/05/2004
User offline. Last seen 2 weeks 2 days ago.

If you don't mind, I'll drop this into MS word so I can give bgetter comments - it's a great piece in need of some sanding here and there, but really good for a first. I'll try to get comments up tonight or tomorrow.

labelleza
[instrumental break]
labelleza's picture
Joined: 09/23/2007
User offline. Last seen 6 hours 57 min ago.

I liked reading this too derek.  I'm not good at critiquing or anything, but I read it and I thought it was interesting. 

Vanderferret
petite and ee-vil
Vanderferret's picture
From: the neon makes it look like Vegas, the trees make it seem like home
Joined: 02/09/2008
User offline. Last seen 1 year 38 weeks ago.

Derek, I think this is a great starting point, and that once you get back in there and start trimming some places and fattening others, you're going to be really happy with how it turns out.  That said, I'm still mulling it over and making notes, so I don't have a lot of "constructive" commentary at the moment.  Hopefully I'll get something else posted here for you in the next day or two.

To leave you with a couple of points from the positive perspective:  I really loved the "alcohol gets out any stain" comment, and I think that comment could (should?) set the tone for the whole story.  It could make or break the piece.  Really good line there.  I also loved when the narrator says, "I think I'm going to see my wife."  Excellent way of putting it.

Barca Boy
Mes Que Un Cultista
Barca Boy's picture
From: Barcelona I wish
Joined: 07/22/2006
User offline. Last seen 18 hours 11 min ago.

Thanks for all the input so far guys. I'm loving what ye are coming up with. It would be nice when I'm finished with it I hve something I'm proud of.

WeeBeasty
WeeBeasty's picture
From: Seattle..
Joined: 03/30/2004
User offline. Last seen 1 year 32 weeks ago.

I like it.

I think structurally and visually you could break up the big paragraph, maybe around this bit  "Can you spare a kidney? If not, a dollar will do".  I think there'd be a bit more impact to move onto the next moment and it'd keep the flow of your narrative a little better.

 

I think you'd do well to maybe play around a little bit with the structure.  Maybe use a few indentation type things to give the visual impression of the brokenness of the narrator.

Overall good stuff I look forward to seeing the final version.

Barca Boy
Mes Que Un Cultista
Barca Boy's picture
From: Barcelona I wish
Joined: 07/22/2006
User offline. Last seen 18 hours 11 min ago.

BUMP

Thanks for the advice, Im just going to bump this once more and then next week I will work on it a bit more. Any more suggestions would be appreciated.

nathaniel parker
Every mile is two in winter.
nathaniel parker's picture
From: East North Pole
Joined: 06/23/2005
User offline. Last seen 10 weeks 4 days ago.

oh wow, I gotta pay more attention to who starts threads in here. I usually just let em all slide. I'll read through it tonight and give ya some coments.

JKabol
yeah, we talked
JKabol's picture
From: le rock
Joined: 12/03/2003
User offline. Last seen 12 weeks 2 days ago.

 

 

 

 

.

 

 

 

im with nate.  except that ive known it was yours.

 

 

have a copy on the base of the bay window, just laying there, that ive read and scribbled on.  thank you for sharing.  read it first during the whiteport anthology idea, before alex m scrapped it.  just havent finished my thoughts yet after you put it here.  family issues, the lawsuit with the car, work is slow, money issues.  all that.  but will get to it.  i promise.

-kabol

 

 

 

 

..

__________________________

__________________________________

play hard, like it's work to be done.